Bernie Sanders’s Jewishness – Hand Gestures And Not Much Else
By: Sara Lehmann
The Jewish Press, February 12th, 2016
The morning after Bernie Sanders’s spectacular performance in the Iowa caucus, New York Post columnist Michael Goodwin, appearing on John Gambling’s radio show, commented on the Vermont senator’s liberal use of hand motions in his speeches. No surprise there, I immediately thought – he talks like an elderly Jew from Brooklyn, steeped in the use of pantomime. But that’s where the similarity ends.
The socialist challenger for the Democratic presidential nomination has been so reticent about his Jewish roots that the media have dubbed him the first “non-religious” contender for president. Leading up to the Iowa caucus, little mention was made of Sanders’s Judaism because of its almost non-existent role in his life.
In a recent interview with the Washington Post, Sanders admitted to not believing in God in a traditional manner. He skirted the issue of belief by offering a vague definition of it. “To me,” he said, “it means that all of us are connected, all of life is connected, and that we are all tied together.” Not a startling admission from a Jew married to a Catholic who spent last Rosh Hashanah campaigning at Liberty University, the evangelical Christian school in Lynchburg, Virginia.
Sanders is nothing if not consistent. His quiet avoidance of anything Jewish, cultural or otherwise, is matched by his avoidance of identification with Israel in the political arena. He was one of only 21 senators during the 2014 Gaza war who didn’t sign Senate Resolution 498, which expressed support for Israel defending itself against “unprovoked attacks” from Hamas. Sanders boycotted Benjamin Netanyahu’s congressional address against negotiations for a nuclear accord with Iran and then supported the Iran deal. In a January 17 debate, he went to so far as to call on the United States to “move as aggressively as we can to normalize relations with Iran.”
While it is still a stretch to envision Sanders as the Democratic nominee and even harder to envision him winning the general election, the frightening takeaway of his surge in popularity is his overwhelming support among young voters. True, idealism is typically found among the young, and even older Democrats are holding their noses while supporting an embattled and imploding Hillary. But enthusiasm for the agnostic Sanders is proving that religion is not dying in America after all – it has simply found a new home. Income inequality, the environment, LGBT rights, and the demonization of Zionism are all part of the new Ten Commandments.
After seven lean years of a president whose agenda indicates he believes in nothing but himself, a divided America is ready for a more robust expression of faith from its next president. And whether it takes the form of Bible-laced references by Ted Cruz, or Donald Trump’s securing of an endorsement by evangelical leader Jerry Falwell Jr., or the deification of secularism by Sanders, the country seems ready to discard theological and political vagueness, if only because people are desperately focused on finding valid expression for their frustrations.
Separation of church and state notwithstanding, the Obama presidency has been a disastrous failure in the experiment of governing from a place far removed from the foundational values of Judeo-Christian beliefs. The steady retreat from divinely ordained rules that form the basis of this country has given us feel-good laws, politically correct madness, and dangerous forays into moral equivalency.
Without a moral compass rooted in faith, ten-percent tithing in Sanders’s world view becomes a ninety-percent tax rate, marriage between a man and a woman is just another option, and refusing to address by name the plague of Islamist extremism is an admirable example of inter-faith sensitivity. Years of pandering to those who proudly flout convention in media, government, and especially educational institutions have rendered America a society bereft of religious convictions and common sense. And it as left America polarized – a country deeply divided between those who drank the progressive Kool-Aid and those who rebel against it.
Though the push from the right is energizing the Republican Party back to the notion of a constitutionally based society, the danger from the left is the ever-accelerating push even further away from the country’s foundational ideals. The Sanders cult is testament to the power the radical left yields over young Americans, who want to out-radicalize Obama’s agenda.
To American Jews who truly care about both America and Israel, this phenomenon is frightening. More young Americans are becoming indoctrinated on college campuses and elsewhere against true Jewish/biblical values and the state of Israel, and it is becoming harder to undo the damage. These are the voters fueling the Sanders campaign.
The spectacle of a 74-year-old Vermont-by-way-of-Brooklyn Jewish Socialist resonating with young urbanites is not surprising, considering how he identifies more with supporting the Black Lives Matter and Occupy Wall Street movements than with protecting American interests at home and abroad. Sanders’s outrageous fiscal promises are shameful – and become dangerous when coupled with his policies that would undermine the security of Israel, America’s other allies, and America itself.
Sanders’s purposeful distancing of himself from his own heritage serves to underscore his estrangement from Israel and Jewish interests and encourages others to do the same. And the image of a Jewish socialist relic who hasn’t learned from history’s mistakes can never be a positive one for Jews, wherever they live.
Sanders’s road to the White House is still a long and doubtful one. Let’s hope that when all is said and done, the lasting image we have of the aforementioned hand movements will be the wringing of those hands in frustrated defeat.
About the Author: Sara Lehmann, a freelance writer living in Brooklyn, was formerly an editor at a major New York publishing house.
II The Brilliant Rabbi Berl Wein weighs in on Bernie
There is a United States senator who represents a small state, Vermont. The people of this small state are different in outlook and temperament than most of the rest of America. They regularly elected to the House of Representatives and then to the Senate a Jew born in Brooklyn, a self-described socialist who is an independent who always votes with the Democratic Party.
To me the wonder is that no one comments upon the fact that this senator, who is running for President, is Jewish! And, add to that, he is a person born in World War II, raised as a secular socialist and throughout his political and legislative career has espoused very left-wing socialist views.
He was always regarded as a somewhat benevolent, quirky senator from a small state. Now he is surprisingly a possible – though he is still a very long shot – contender for the presidency of the United States. He is the first Jew in the history of the United States to win a presidential primary election, having crushed Hillary Clinton in the recent New Hampshire primary.
How ironic but tellingly true that the first Jew to get this far in a presidential race is a left-wing socialist with no real identity with the Jewish people and the Jewish faith!
The twentieth century has provided us with ample examples of such Jews who have risen high in politics and government. Leon Blum, Walter Rathenau, Leon Trotsky, Bela Kun, etc. were all Jews who rose to power but whose policies and beliefs eventually led to national and international disaster.
Much of the ideals of the Left are based on Torah values. Fairness to workers, non-exploitation of the defenseless and the lower class, compassion for others and helping the less fortunate are all Torah values. The problem lies not so much in the ideas, as it does in the implementation of those ideas. That is where secular socialism has wrecked societies and literally killed millions of otherwise innocent people.
Bernie is the unrepentant Jewish socialist whom I knew so well in my youth. They were convinced that they were the wave of the future and that the old-fashioned Jew – especially the observant religious Jew – was doomed to extinction. The old-fashioned socialist Jew has morphed into the modern, liberal, assimilationist American Jew. And those are the qualities to which the vast majority of American Jews subscribe.
The triumph of the Left in America is based on its triumph in capturing the hearts, minds, belief and pocketbooks of most of American Jewry. So then why does Bernie Sanders resonate less with American Jews than does his rival, Hillary Clinton?
Part of the reason for this is that Jews distrust other Jews being in power. This is a subconscious but very omnipresent lesson of centuries of exile and anti-Semitism. There are many in the Jewish community who feel that Jews in power inevitably exacerbate the latent anti-Semitism which exists.
In Israel governing is made very difficult simply because Jews have to govern over other Jews. After thousands of years of abject servitude, it is painful to have to make the necessary mindset adjustment to a Jewish government. So, I have little hope that Bernie will make it big with the American Jewish community while Hillary will certainly prove popular, no matter her past, her policies, her personality or any other qualities she may possess.
We are a strange people. When Senator Joseph Lieberman was the nominee of the Democratic Party for Vice-President I remember that many Jews who regularly voted Democratic were very hesitant that year to vote that way. They were deathly afraid of a Jewish Vice-President of the United States of America.
Of course Lieberman was and is a different type of Jew than is Bernie. But to the non-Jewish society, a Jew is a Jew, is a Jew.
Meanwhile, Bernie, thanks for the memories and the ride. (But, I could hardly wish you good luck and lie while my G-d is listening) jsk
Berel Wein (born March 25, 1934) is an American-born Orthodox rabbi, lecturer and writer. He authored several books concerning Jewish history and popularized the subject through more than 1,000 audio tapes, newspaper articles and international lectures. Throughout his career, he has retained personal and ideological ties to both Modern Orthodox and Haredi Judaism. Rabbi Wein and his wife moved to Israel in 1997. In Israel, Wein established The Destiny Foundation, a forum for his CDs, audio tapes and many books.
Subscribe Israel Commentary: www.israel-commentary.org